Battle Outcome Debate Page

[1D1P1J]

... but I had only the voices in my head to argue with (they usually win those arguments btw).

LOL!

OK, I've got another battle for people to decipher. The tech levels are as follows:

Attakcer's Tech Levels: Med, WC, Met = LVL 8 RD and Dragonry LVL 9

Defender's Tech Levels: Med, WC, Met, Drag = LVL 8 RD = LVL 9



Discuss!

[joelius141]

i am going to guess the attacker got wiped, but took with him the 53k swifts and a good chunk of BD's, also the attacker is retarded. also what does rapid deployment have to do with the battle outcome?

[1D1P1J]

i am going to guess the attacker got wiped, but took with him the 53k swifts and a good chunk of BD's, also the attacker is retarded. also what does rapid deployment have to do with the battle outcome?

I think that Rapid Deployment will affect how quickly the troops cross the field.

If RD isn't levelled up enough and ranged troops are used in conjunction with dragons they may not be able to cross the field and therefore lose initiative. I'm not certain on this though.

Also, relax on the insults! Even losing attacks can serve a purpose in the greater scheme of things.

[naib]

attack was defeated. atacking troops separated due troop speed difference. RD would not have played any roll in this because RD affects all troops. Attacking BD targeted the defender BD as the threat and got wiped in 1-2 rounds. defending swift went for the range and suffered loss but I dont think heavy loss because the had cover fire from defending LBM and fang. end result goes to defender with minimal loss. I will enjoy this thread but refuse to use a calc since you rarely have time to do so in large battles where attackers uses speed. most times you barely have time to read the report.

[naib]

waited 20 hrs. hope you give the answer soon. game is no fun if you have to wait forever.

[1D1P1J]

I was hoping to get another few in before I gave the answer:

Here it is



You were right that the attack was defeated.

For some reason I had RD confused with Dragonry. I thought I had read somewhere that once RD was above Level 7 you stop losing BDs when attacking camps in appropriate numbers. I won't bother including it any more.

Bit of a shocking result this one.

In the end the attacker could prob have won it with another 30k BDs in the army.

[evicton]

Actually for the attacker in that one RD does matter you were right for including it, especially with the Fangs, Both rd and dragonry affect the movement speed of all units.

At first I thought the results were pretty shocking too till I looked back. attackers dragonry was a higher level and while we don't know exactly what all dragonry affects, I'm putting the high loss of bds in this fight directly on that.

[Ardus]

Wow the above pic sucks for defenders. I do not consider that a "minimal" loss. I understand what happened, but holy hell it seems the attacker won more from that than the defender lol. Defender lost more than half his BDs and all his Swifts!!!!

[Ardus]

^ I'll do one, but only one....

If Attacker had high enough Techs for the Bowmen to get first attack:
Bowmen sent 6.4mil damage at the defending Minos and Swifts killing the Minos, possibly kill some Swifts.
Defending Dragons advanced and slaughter the the Bowmen.

If Attacker could not cross base distance to use initiative:
Bowmen moved up, just inside of Dragon range but not close enough to fire.
Dragons crossed the Field and Swifts hit the Bowmen, no losses.
Bowmen fire their first attack at the Dragons killing all Swifts.
BDs move up and slaughter the Bowmen.

What do you mean by "If Attacker had high enough Techs for the Bowmen to get first attack", what's a good level?

[naib]

wow. I am shocked at the amount of loss of defending BD. Either RNG or its back to school time. tomorrow I will post a multi wave battle and let you play with it.