Please help me to understand this battle report, did the WMC set the range?

[abagail]

I am having trouble understand this report in general, not the how the range was set.





Attackers () Winner
Knight Combat Skill: 255
Attack Boosted: 20%
Defense Boosted: 20%
Throne Room Bonuses:
Defense: 480%
Combat Speed: 17%
Range: 88%
Attack Debuff: -29%
Defense Debuff: -65%
Life Debuff: -55%
Combat Speed Debuff: -17%
Range Debuff: -36%
Infantry Combat Speed Debuff: -17%
Horsed Combat Speed: 36%
Horsed Defense Debuff: -8%
Horsed Accuracy Bonus Debuff: -0.22%
Siege Load Debuff: -25%
Reassign March Speed: 60%
Troop Training Speed: 80%
Wood Production: 90%
Stone Production: 160%
Ore Production: 140%
undefined: 15%
Attack Results:
()
Troops Fought Survived
Heavy Cavalry 250,000 224,958

Defenders ()
Knight Combat Skill: 156


Throne Room Bonuses:
Defense: 98%
Combat Speed: 3%
Bonus to PvP on Offense: 2%
Bonus vs. Barbarian Camps: 60%
Bonus to Wall: 870%
Defense Debuff: -105%
Combat Speed Debuff: -28%
Range Debuff: -1%
Load Debuff: -11%
Ranged Attack: 10%
Ranged Defense Debuff: -1%
Reassign March Speed: 30%
Food Production: 10%
Stone Production: 10%
Ore Production: 30%
Defense Results:
Rounds: 8
Troops Fought Survived
Militiaman 407,473 0
Scout 1,152,184 0
Pikeman 116,006 0
Archer 406,841 0
Supply Wagon 60,000 0
Crossbows 16,500 0
Trebuchet 1,499 1,499

[fdiniz]

I am having trouble understand this report in general, not the how the range was set.





Attackers () Winner
Knight Combat Skill: 255
Attack Boosted: 20%
Defense Boosted: 20%
Throne Room Bonuses:
Defense: 480%
Combat Speed: 17%
Range: 88%
Attack Debuff: -29%
Defense Debuff: -65%
Life Debuff: -55%
Combat Speed Debuff: -17%
Range Debuff: -36%
Infantry Combat Speed Debuff: -17%
Horsed Combat Speed: 36%
Horsed Defense Debuff: -8%
Horsed Accuracy Bonus Debuff: -0.22%
Siege Load Debuff: -25%
Reassign March Speed: 60%
Troop Training Speed: 80%
Wood Production: 90%
Stone Production: 160%
Ore Production: 140%
undefined: 15%
Attack Results:
()
Troops Fought Survived
Heavy Cavalry 250,000 224,958

Defenders ()
Knight Combat Skill: 156


Throne Room Bonuses:
Defense: 98%
Combat Speed: 3%
Bonus to PvP on Offense: 2%
Bonus vs. Barbarian Camps: 60%
Bonus to Wall: 870%
Defense Debuff: -105%
Combat Speed Debuff: -28%
Range Debuff: -1%
Load Debuff: -11%
Ranged Attack: 10%
Ranged Defense Debuff: -1%
Reassign March Speed: 30%
Food Production: 10%
Stone Production: 10%
Ore Production: 30%
Defense Results:
Rounds: 8
Troops Fought Survived
Militiaman 407,473 0
Scout 1,152,184 0
Pikeman 116,006 0
Archer 406,841 0
Supply Wagon 60,000 0
Crossbows 16,500 0
Trebuchet 1,499 1,499

Yes, they did. An easy way to check (if you are in the battle, of course) is to look at troop stats.

The HC did great against the archers because of the big defense buff the attacker has. He probably made his defense higher than the archers attack (i didn't do the math).

[former noob]

Defense higher then both the arch and the pike attack stats. HC losses were primarily due to the Xbows which would have been the last thing killed. The defender not having an active ore guardian and a low level knight also contributed to these results as both contributed to lower attack stats for the defending arch and pike. An active ore guardian, better knight, a little attack buff or defense debuff by the defender could have given very different results. This amount of defense would not have been enough to do this if the defender had a 255 knight in the city.

Before you start about the ore guardian I am assuming that since the defender had a low level knight that he also does not have a full guardian set. If you do not have the full guardian set the ore guardian will contribute to the attack stat when it is active and you are defending. And yes I know what the guardian says.