http://community.kabam.com/forums/ Need help understanding your battle reports? Post them here and get help from you fellow Lords and Ladies! en Sun, 19 May 2013 04:12:34 GMT vBulletin 60 http://community.kabam.com/forums/images/styles/BlissfullySimple/misc/rss.png http://community.kabam.com/forums/ http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?177015-I-dont-understand-why-i-did-kill-defenders-ballista-s&goto=newpost Sat, 18 May 2013 20:54:50 GMT edit* I dont understand why i didnt kill defenders ballista's

Im the attacker, i have maxed research and briton research, i attacked from a fey city with a Lv.10 Fey Altar and Dark Ritual Blessing...
both my ballista and hc was sacrificed.
i dont understand why my ballista have 200+ less range than defenders and my hc has less range than defenders? we both range debuffed each other!
this isnt the 1st time ive noticed this happen i often fully range debuff players and notice they still have more range than me....
someone please help me with this! its has to be a glitch or something isnt being applied


Battle at (xxx,xxx) May 18, 04:19 AM
Report No: 89054067

Glory Gained: 892
Attackers (xxxx)
Knight Combat Skill: 255
Attack Boosted: 20%
Defense Boosted: 20%
Guardian Attack Boost: 97.5%
Guardian Training Boost: 17.5%

Attack Results:
Might Lost: 4,820,000
(xxx,xxx) undefined
Troops Fought Survived Killed Unit Stats:
Scout 10,000 0 (10,000) HP: 61 Atk: 150.9245625 Def: 7.175 Spd: 10,200 Rng: 15
Heavy Cavalry 300,000 0 (300,000) HP: 7,930 Atk: 22,890.2253125 Def: 811.4925 Spd: 4,485 Rng: 78
Ballista 300,000 0 (300,000) HP: 2,537.6 Atk: 29,430.2896875 Def: 373.1 Spd: 396.5 Rng: 2,821

Throne Room Bonuses:
Attack: 1954%
Defense: 370%
Life: 145%
Combat Speed: 145%
Bonus vs. Dark Forests: 50%
Defense Debuff: -1705%
Range Debuff: -72.5%
Accuracy Debuff: -0.5%
Infantry Combat Speed: 95%
Infantry Defense Debuff: -95%
Horsed Attack: 590%
Horsed Combat Speed: 192%
Siege Attack Debuff: -72.5%


Defenders (xxxx) Winner
Knight Combat Skill: 255
Attack Boosted: 50%
Defense Boosted: 20%
Guardian Training Boost: 35.0%

Defense Results:
Might Lost: 744,145
Rounds: 2
Troops Fought Survived Killed Unit Stats:
Militiaman ??? ??? 0 HP: 1,342 Atk: 407.5 Def: 227.955 Spd: 200 Rng: 15
Pikeman ??? ??? 0 HP: 2,013 Atk: 1,222.5 Def: 578.655 Spd: 300 Rng: 37.5
Swordsman ??? ??? 0 HP: 2,348.5 Atk: 815 Def: 1,104.705 Spd: 275 Rng: 22.5
Archer ??? ??? 0 HP: 1,980 Atk: 978 Def: 447.875 Spd: 250 Rng: 1,860
Cavalry ??? ??? 0 HP: 3,355 Atk: 2,832.5 Def: 1,066.725 Spd: 1,790 Rng: 75
Heavy Cavalry ??? ??? (106,264) HP: 9,394 Atk: 5,551.7 Def: 2,887.269 Spd: 1,879.5 Rng: 84
Supply Wagon ??? ??? 0 HP: 4,697 Atk: 81.5 Def: 277.275 Spd: 240 Rng: 7.5
Ballista ??? ??? 0 HP: 3,006.08 Atk: 4,473 Def: 1,035.16 Spd: 224 Rng: 3,038
Battering Ram ??? ??? 0 HP: 33,550 Atk: 1,775 Def: 739.4 Spd: 192 Rng: 450
Bloodthorn ??? ??? 0 HP: 7,045.5 Atk: 5,297.5 Def: 789.075 Spd: 900 Rng: 112.5
Executioner ??? ??? 0 HP: 14,091 Atk: 6,927.5 Def: 1,227.45 Spd: 500 Rng: 90
Trap ??? ??? (99) HP: 0 Atk: 5,000 Def: 0 Spd: 0 Rng: 0

Throne Room Bonuses:
Defense: 3206%
Life: 145%
Attack Debuff: -1057%
Range Debuff: -72.5%
Accuracy Debuff: -0.5%
Ranged Defense: 38%
Ranged Life: 77%
Horsed Attack: 159%
Horsed Defense: 522%
Horsed Combat Speed: 19%
Horsed Load Debuff: -77%
Siege Attack Debuff: -72.5%
March Speed: 18.5% ]]> Battle Reports Explained Skusey http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?177015-I-dont-understand-why-i-did-kill-defenders-ballista-s http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?176654-why-did-the-cats-not-win&goto=newpost Thu, 16 May 2013 23:14:28 GMT i am pretty sure i mathed this right,, both players should be range capped, so i must be missing something,, why do the attackers bals out range the defenders cats. cats were saced,, defender double checked and time was remaining. Glory Gained:... i am pretty sure i mathed this right,, both players should be range capped, so i must be missing something,, why do the attackers bals out range the defenders cats. cats were saced,, defender double checked and time was remaining.

Glory Gained: 0
Attackers (attacker)
Knight Combat Skill: 255
Attack Boosted: 0%
Defense Boosted: 0%
Guardian Attack Boost: 97.5%

Guardian March Speed Boost: 0.5%
Guardian Training Boost: 65.0%
Attack Results:
Might Lost: 3,434,300
(138,253) undefined
Troops Fought Survived Killed
Heavy Cavalry 50,000 0 (50,000)
Ballista 342,700 0 (342,700)
Unit Stats:
HP: 6,100 Atk: 3,684.3625 Def: 454.575 Spd: 1,627.5 Rng: 104
HP: 2,732.8 Atk: 6,532.3125 Def: 292.6 Spd: 303.8 Rng: 3,038
Throne Room Bonuses:
Defense: 370%
Life: 145%
Combat Speed: 57%
Range: 292.5%
Load: 400%
Bonus vs. Barbarian Camps: 118%
Defense Debuff: -185%
Life Debuff: -23.5%
Combat Speed Debuff: -57%
Range Debuff: -435.5%
Load Debuff: -105%
Accuracy Debuff: -0.5%
Infantry Attack: 172%
Ranged Defense: 19%
Horsed Attack: 195%
Horsed Combat Speed Debuff: -47%
Siege Attack Debuff: -72.5%
Siege Range Debuff: -57%
Wood Production: 145%
Ore Production: 145%
Briton Research Bonuses:
Improved Cartography 0.5
Improved Defenses 0.5
Strengthen Ranks 0.2
Improved Fletching 0.2

Defenders (defender) Winner
Knight Combat Skill: 255
Attack Boosted: 20%
Defense Boosted: 20%

Guardian Life Boost: 12.5%

Guardian Training Boost: 195.0%
Defense Results:
Might Lost: 5,992,760
Rounds: 3
Troops Fought Survived Killed
Scout 3,060,400 1,714,020 (1,346,380)
Cavalry 330,000 330,000
Heavy Cavalry 430,000 430,000
Catapult 330,000 0 (330,000)
Executioner 100,000 100,000
Unit Stats:
HP: 30.7125 Atk: 26.73 Def: 6.975 Spd: 12,000 Rng: 15
HP: 1,535.625 Atk: 2,112.5 Def: 313.875 Spd: 2,580 Rng: 75
HP: 3,071.25 Atk: 2,957.5 Def: 606.825 Spd: 1,935 Rng: 60
HP: 1,916.46 Atk: 4,407 Def: 453.375 Spd: 317.2 Rng: 3,022.5
HP: 8,384.5125 Atk: 9,845.55 Def: 634.725 Spd: 2,600 Rng: 117
Throne Room Bonuses:
Defense: 555%
Combat Speed: 202%
Range: 386.5%
Load: 50%
Attack Debuff: -236%
Defense Debuff: -155%
Range Debuff: -262.5%
Infantry Attack: 118%
Infantry Combat Speed: 195%
Infantry Combat Speed Debuff: -19%
Horsed Attack: 95%
Horsed Load Debuff: -77%
Siege Range Debuff: -57%
Siege Load Debuff: -95%
Reinforcement March Speed: 200%
Troop Training Speed: 102%
Construction Speed: 159%
Food Production: 455%
Briton Bonus 1: 15%
Briton Research Bonuses:
Improved Cartography 0.5
Improved Defenses 0.5
Strengthen Ranks 0.2
Improved Fletching 0.2 ]]> Battle Reports Explained just wow http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?176654-why-did-the-cats-not-win http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?175963-Can-someone-explain-how-the-attacker-killed-so-many-here&goto=newpost Tue, 14 May 2013 01:04:45 GMT Can't figure this one out.... thx


Glory Gained: 0
Attackers (xxxxxxx)
Knight Combat Skill: 116
Attack Boosted: 20%
Defense Boosted: 20%
Guardian Attack Boost: 32.0%



Attack Results:
Might Lost: 1,039,500
(417,638) undefined
Troops Fought Survived Killed
Heavy Cavalry 148,500 0 (148,500)
Unit Stats:
HP: 2,720 Atk: 8,909.5776 Def: 240.1896 Spd: 1,530 Rng: 272
Throne Room Bonuses:
Attack: 479%
Range: 192%
Load: 41%
Attack Debuff: -38%
Defense Debuff: -1112%
Life Debuff: -19%
Range Debuff: -97%
Infantry Combat Speed: 77%
Infantry Attack Debuff: -19%
Infantry Defense Debuff: -154%
Siege Attack: 82%
Siege Range: 57%
Siege Load: 133%
Briton Research Bonuses:
Improved Cartography 0.5
Improved Defenses 0.5
Strengthen Ranks 0.2
Improved Fletching 0.2

Defenders (xxxxxxxx) Winner
Knight Combat Skill: 255
Attack Boosted: 20%
Defense Boosted: 20%

Guardian Life Boost: 10.0%

Guardian Training Boost: 35.0%
Defense Results:
Might Lost: 2,079,000
Rounds: 2
Troops Fought Survived Killed
Heavy Cavalry 347,100 50,100 (297,000)
Unit Stats:
HP: 6,226 Atk: 7,752.5 Def: 328.425 Spd: 2,025 Rng: 60
Throne Room Bonuses:
Attack: 1233%
Defense: 782%
Combat Speed: 115%
Attack Debuff: -38%
Defense Debuff: -483%
Life Debuff: -195%
Range Debuff: -17%
Load Debuff: -33%
Horsed Attack: 108%
Horsed Defense: 360%
Horsed Life: 142%
Horsed Load: 71%
March Size: 11.5%
Reinforcement March Speed: 80%
Troop Training Speed: 42%
Construction Speed: 69%
Druid Bonus 1: 15%
Briton Research Bonuses:
Improved Cartography 0.5
Improved Defenses 0.5
Strengthen Ranks 0.2
Improved Fletching 0.2 ]]> Battle Reports Explained Rupert8 http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?175963-Can-someone-explain-how-the-attacker-killed-so-many-here http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?175940-Confusing-Report-Please-Help&goto=newpost Mon, 13 May 2013 21:43:06 GMT Hi there Everyone! I have a Report that I don´t quite understand... How was the Attacker able to take out so many HC with so little losses? AND: Why didn´t all of his Troops get killed as there were still a load of HC in the defending city? Thanks... Hi there Everyone!
I have a Report that I don´t quite understand... How was the Attacker able to take out so many HC with so little losses?
AND: Why didn´t all of his Troops get killed as there were still a load of HC in the defending city? Thanks in advance for any answers! Sorry if I posted this wrong!


Attackers
Knight Combat Skill: 124
Attack Boosted: 0%
Defense Boosted: 0%
Guardian Attack Boost: 60.0%

Guardian March Speed Boost: 4.0%
Guardian Training Boost: 17.5%
Attack Results:
Might Lost: 204,363

Troops Fought Survived Killed
Pikeman 49,500 49,090 (410)
Archer 100,000 99,173 (827)
Heavy Cavalry 20,000 0 (20,000)
Executioner 10,000 7,745 (2,255)
Siege Wall 2,000 0 (2,000)
Unit Stats:
HP: 900 Atk: 897.6 Def: 881.76 Spd: 150 Rng: 50
HP: 750 Atk: 718.08 Def: 668 Spd: 125 Rng: 1,800
HP: 4,200 Atk: 2,932.16 Def: 3,756.312 Spd: 997.5 Rng: 112
HP: 6,300 Atk: 5,086.4 Def: 1,870.4 Spd: 250 Rng: 120
HP: 17,640 Atk: 837.76 Def: 5,237.12 Spd: 542.5 Rng: 168
Throne Room Bonuses:
Defense: 2555%
Load: 90%
Bonus to Wall: 165%
Attack Debuff: -336%
Defense Debuff: -580%
Horsed Defense: 412%
Horsed Combat Speed: 38%
Horsed Defense Debuff: -94%
Horsed Combat Speed Debuff: -30%
Siege Attack: 15%
Siege Combat Speed: 40%
Reassign March Speed: 132%
Troop Training Speed: 220%
Resource Production: 122%
Wood Production: 94%
Stone Production: 118%
Fey Bonus 1: 15%
Briton Research Bonuses:
Improved Cartography 0.35
Improved Defenses 0
Strengthen Ranks 0.18
Improved Fletching 0

Defenders Winner
Knight Combat Skill: 100



Guardian Life Boost: 2.0%


Defense Results:
Might Lost: 2,393,066
Rounds: 100
Troops Fought Survived Killed
Scout 401,115 0 (401,115)
Heavy Cavalry 1,356,200 1,148,152 (208,048)
Siege Wall 10,000 0 (10,000)
Trebuchet 1,000 1,000
Trap 1,500 0 (1,500)
Unit Stats:
HP: 30.6 Atk: 10.5 Def: 30.43 Spd: 3,000 Rng: 20
HP: 5,465.568 Atk: 1,666 Def: 3,517.6536 Spd: 1,173 Rng: 108.8
HP: 12,852 Atk: 350 Def: 4,095 Spd: 775 Rng: 120
HP: 0 Atk: 2,550 Def: 0 Spd: 0 Rng: 0
HP: 0 Atk: 5,000 Def: 0 Spd: 0 Rng: 0
Throne Room Bonuses:
Defense: 3310%
Attack Debuff: -1010%
Defense Debuff: -95%
Combat Speed Debuff: -95%
Infantry Defense: 118%
Horsed Defense: 142%
Horsed Life: 47%
Horsed Load: 71%
March Speed: 14.5%
Troop Training Speed: 124%
Upkeep Reduction: 26%
Research Speed: 54%
Aetherstone Cap: 47%
Storehouse Protection: 73%
Briton Bonus 1: 15%
Briton Research Bonuses:
Improved Cartography 0.5
Improved Defenses 0.5
Strengthen Ranks 0.2
Improved Fletching 0.2 ]]> Battle Reports Explained Dee Kay http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?175940-Confusing-Report-Please-Help http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?175864-can-someone-help-me-understand-this-rep-plz-i-need-to-know-where-i-lost-out&goto=newpost Mon, 13 May 2013 14:47:49 GMT ok peeps i hit this guy with a small troop count as i was unsure if i could beat him i was fairly confident due to attack debuff however saying that i thought if i lost i'd take out a fair few troops at least !!! if only that was the case!!!
can anyone plz explain what happened here as looking at each individual stat i beat him except range for seige and life on rams so how did i lose in 2nd round did his rams slow me for his cats to kill me before my next move???

If so what do i need to add to compensate more seigewall maybe and some speed defence? ;)
thanks for your help in advance :)

Attackers:
Knight Combat Skill: 255
Might lost: 1,953,500
Wounded might: 781,400
Troops got overwhelmed!!

Defenders: ) Winner
Knight Combat Skill: 255
Might lost: 69,734
Wounded might: ?
Rounds: 2

my troops
Fought Survived Wounded
cavs 100,000 0 (100,000) 40,000 (40%)
hcavs 200,000 0 (200,000) 80,000 (40%)
executioner 2,700 0 (2,700) 1,080 (40%)
seige wall 1,000 0 (1,000) 400 (40%)

his troops
Fought Survived Wounded
mm 0 0 ?
scouts 0 0 ?
pike 0 0 ?
swords 0 0 ?
archers 0 0 ?
hcavs 9,962 0 (9,962) ?
wags 0 0 ?
rams 0 0 ?
ballis 0 0 ?
cats 0 0 ?
blood 0 0 ?
exec. 0 0 ?


my stats attacking
cavs hp: 3,600 (260%) atk: 12,577 (2415%) def: 125 (178%)
spd: 1,050 (5%) rng: 163 (63%) ld: 246 (146%)
hcav hp: 10,080 (404%) atk: 24,651 (3422%) def: 338 (289%)
spd: 1,103 (47%) rng: 183 (129%) ld: 276 (245%)
exec hp: 14,406 (243%) atk: 42,762 (2415%) def: 194 (177%)
spd: 250 (-100%) rng: 196 (63%) ld: 1,230 (146%)
seigewall hp: 40,337 (380%) atk: 7,043 (3422%) def: 544 (289%)
spd: 543 (-43%) rng: 274 (128%) ld: 1,722 (244%)


his troop stats defending
mm hp: 640 (60%) atk: 1,108 (1008%) def: 37 (185%)
spd: 200 rng: 15 (-33%)
scouts hp: 32 (60%) atk: 66 (1000%) def: 3 (200%)
spd: 3,000 rng: 15 (-33%)
pikes hp: 960 (60%) atk: 3,323 (1008%) def: 93 (182%)
spd: 300 rng: 38 (-32%)
swords hp: 1,120 (60%) atk: 2,215 (1007%) def: 178 (183%)
spd: 275 rng: 23 (-30%)
archers hp: 800 (60%) atk: 2,658 (1007%) def: 71 (184%)
spd: 250 rng: 1,860 (55%)
hcavs hp: 2,200 (10%) atk: 7,753 (1008%) def: 246 (183%)
spd: 1,200 (60%) rng: 60 (-33%)
wags hp: 2,240 (60%) atk: 222 (1010%) def: 42 (180%)
spd: 240 (60%) rng: 8 (-25%)
rams hp: 1,024 (60%) atk: 9,968 (1008%) def: 113 (183%)
spd: 160 (60%) rng: 2,170 (55%)
ballis hp: 16,000 (60%) atk: 5,538 (1008%) def: 113 (183%)
spd: 192 (60%) rng: 450 (-33%)
cats hp: 1,536 (60%) atk: 13,290 (1007%) def: 141 (182%)
spd: 128 (60%) rng: 2,325 (55%)
blood hp: 3,360 (60%) atk: 14,398 (1008%) def: 127 (182%)
spd: 900 rng: 113 (-33%)
exec hp: 6,720 (60%) atk: 18,828 (1008%) def: 198 (183%)
spd: 500 rng: 90 (-33%)

Castle Life: 66,000,000 / 66,000,000

BOOSTS

mine
Attack boost: 20%
Defense boost: 20%
Guardian Attack boost: 98%

his
Attack boost: 20%
Defense boost: 20%

mine
Life 60%
Attack 60%
Defense 55%
Speed 55%
Range 60%
Load 120%
Improved Cartography 50%
Improved Defenses 30%
Strengthen Ranks 20%
Improved Fletching 20%

his
Life 60%
Attack 60%
Defense 60%
Speed 60%
Range 60%
Improved Cartography 50%
Improved Defenses 50%
Strengthen Ranks 20%
Improved Fletching 20%


my tr stats
THRONE ITEMS
-181% Defense Debuff
272% Horsed Attack
1248% Attack
183% Life
-72.5% Siege Attack Debuff
-0.5% Accuracy Debuff
370% Defense
-72.5% Range Debuff
-512% Attack Debuff
3100% Bonus to Wall
-47% Horsed Load Debuff
-47% Infantry Attack Debuff
-72.5% Horsed Life Debuff
265% Horsed Defense
63% Range
26% Load
23% Horsed Life
23% Chance to Find Items


his tr stats
-194% Attack Debuff
-38% Infantry Attack Debuff
1476% Attack
0.37% Accuracy
61% Reassign March Speed
198% Food Production
188% Resource Production
220% Troop Training Speed
-832% Defense Debuff
-77% Combat Speed Debuff
-479% Horsed Defense Debuff
-77% Ranged Defense Debuff
38% Bonus to PvP on Defense
87% Horsed Load
164% Bonus vs. Barbarian Camps
159% Horsed Attack ]]> Battle Reports Explained loopy2013 http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?175864-can-someone-help-me-understand-this-rep-plz-i-need-to-know-where-i-lost-out http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?175597-How-are-research-bonuses-calculated&goto=newpost Sat, 11 May 2013 23:30:57 GMT Can someone please tell me how the research bonuses are calculated in the attack reports? I thought they were based on the specific research items (poisoned edge=attack, metal alloys=def, fletching=range, healing potions=life, ?=speed), but I... Can someone please tell me how the research bonuses are calculated in the attack reports?

I thought they were based on the specific research items (poisoned edge=attack, metal alloys=def, fletching=range, healing potions=life, ?=speed), but I have all these at level 11 so should all be 55%, yet my attack reports only show the following:

Research
Life: 45%
Attack: 45%
Defense: 45%
Speed: 45%
Range: 45%

are there any buff or debuff lines that affect these?

thanks ]]> Battle Reports Explained GWW http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?175597-How-are-research-bonuses-calculated http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?174950-HC-and-Def-Atk&goto=newpost Thu, 09 May 2013 04:50:19 GMT Still an active player, but spending most time anymore reading battle reports and trying to understand battle mechanics. This recent report brings up a couple things: 1. Are HC with +Def that unstoppable? 2. Given max Lab/Workshop research, are... Still an active player, but spending most time anymore reading battle reports and trying to understand battle mechanics. This recent report brings up a couple things:

1. Are HC with +Def that unstoppable?
2. Given max Lab/Workshop research, are caps still in place (wondering because of the +Def/-Atk here (attack greatly debuffed))?
3. What's the easiest way to get max rounds (with maybe 3 types of troops)?



Battle at (123,456) May 01, 03:35 PM
Report No: 168850636
Attackers breached the walls.

Glory Gained: 68
Loot:
Gold 82,485
Food 23,993,768
Wood 34,768,435
Stone 3,256,650
Ore 52,567

Attackers (qwerty) Winner
Knight Combat Skill: 255
Attack Boosted: 20%
Defense Boosted: 20%
Attack Results:
Might Lost: 544,264
(107,502) undefined
Troops Fought Survived Killed
Heavy Cavalry 330,000 252,248 (77,752)
Unit Stats:
HP: 6,944 Atk: 5,253.22875 Def: 5,246.535 Spd: 3,696 Rng: 84

Throne Room Bonuses:
Defense: 3395%
Life: 145%
Combat Speed: 145%
Attack Debuff: -1019%
Defense Debuff: -95%
Range Debuff: -72.5%
Accuracy Debuff: -0.5%
Infantry Attack: 95%
Infantry Combat Speed Debuff: -23.5%
Ranged Defense: 47%
Horsed Defense: 840%
Horsed Combat Speed: 47%
Siege Attack Debuff: -72.5%
Briton Bonus 1: 15%

Defenders (asdfgh)
Knight Combat Skill: 255
Attack Boosted: 20%
Defense Boosted: 20%
Defense Results:
Might Lost: 140,393,280
Rounds: 93
Troops Fought Survived Killed
Militiaman 1,574,453 0 (1,574,453)
Scout 8,859,875 0 (8,859,875)
Pikeman 10,367 0 (10,367)
Swordsman 19,792 0 (19,792)
Archer 11,149,116 11,149,116
Cavalry 5,173,153 0 (5,173,153)
Heavy Cavalry 3,020,986 0 (3,020,986)
Supply Wagon 4,900,771 0 (4,900,771)
Ballista 3,509,101 0 (3,509,101)
Battering Ram 46,544 0 (46,544)
Catapult 1,067,632 0 (1,067,632)
Executioner 125,829 0 (125,829)
Crossbows 500 0 (500)
Trebuchet 8,000 8,000
Trap 8,249 0 (8,249)
Unit Stats:
HP: 1,317.6 Atk: 282.5 Def: 93.275 Spd: 153 Rng: 50
HP: 65.88 Atk: 16.95 Def: 7.175 Spd: 2,295 Rng: 50
HP: 1,976.4 Atk: 847.5 Def: 236.775 Spd: 229.5 Rng: 125
HP: 2,305.8 Atk: 565 Def: 452.025 Spd: 210.375 Rng: 75
HP: 1,647 Atk: 704.4 Def: 179.375 Spd: 191.25 Rng: 3,960
HP: 3,294 Atk: 1,412.5 Def: 322.875 Spd: 1,600 Rng: 250
HP: 6,588 Atk: 1,977.5 Def: 624.225 Spd: 1,200 Rng: 200
HP: 4,611.6 Atk: 56.5 Def: 107.625 Spd: 240 Rng: 25
HP: 2,108.16 Atk: 2,542.5 Def: 287 Spd: 160 Rng: 4,620
HP: 32,940 Atk: 1,412.5 Def: 287 Spd: 192 Rng: 1,500
HP: 3,162.24 Atk: 3,390 Def: 358.75 Spd: 128 Rng: 4,950
HP: 13,834.8 Atk: 4,802.5 Def: 502.25 Spd: 500 Rng: 300
HP: 3,200 Atk: 2,385 Def: 112 Spd: 0 Rng: 2,340
HP: 0 Atk: 2,550 Def: 0 Spd: 0 Rng: 0
HP: 0 Atk: 5,000 Def: 0 Spd: 0 Rng: 0

Throne Room Bonuses:
Attack: 364%
Defense: 465%
Life: 145%
Range: 258%
Load: 592%
Attack Debuff: -597%
Defense Debuff: -77%
Life Debuff: -57%
Range Debuff: -72.5%
Accuracy Debuff: -0.5%
Infantry Attack: 95%
Infantry Combat Speed Debuff: -38%
Ranged Attack: 506%
Ranged Range: 19%
Ranged Accuracy Bonus: 0.82%
Ranged Life Debuff: -77%
Horsed Defense Debuff: -38%
Siege Attack Debuff: -72.5%
Troop Training Speed: 50%
Briton Bonus 1: 15% ]]> Battle Reports Explained NattyIce374 http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?174950-HC-and-Def-Atk http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?174746-ever-seen-anything-like-this&goto=newpost Wed, 08 May 2013 07:40:17 GMT You were Victorious! Battle at (286,142) - May 08, 03:31 AM Report No: 161200365 Glory Gained: 61 Ore: 0 Wood: 0 Stone: 0 Food: You were Victorious!
Battle at (286,142) - May 08, 03:31 AM Report No: 161200365
Glory Gained: 61
Ore:
0
Wood:
0
Stone:
0
Food:
0
Gold:
0
Attackers: (XXXXXXX)
(282,150)
Knight Combat Skill:216
Knight Level:1
Throne RoomAttack
Defenders: XXXXXX
(286,142) Winner
Knight Combat Skill:255
Throne RoomInventory
Troops
Fought Survived Wounded
[Archer] 457,500 457,500 ?
[Heavy Cavalry] 450,000 380,274 ?
Fought Survived Wounded
[Militiaman] 624,144 624,144 0
[Pikeman] 159,933 159,933 0
[Swordsman] 156,438 156,438 0
[Archer] 670,208 670,208 0
[Heavy Cavalry] 1,821,934 1,817,306 1,851
[Ballista] 385,644 375,228 4,166
[Battering Ram] 20,000 20,000 0
[Executioner] 2,346 2,346 0 ]]> Battle Reports Explained GuyWolfe http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?174746-ever-seen-anything-like-this http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?173240-Can-someone-explain-this-report&goto=newpost Wed, 01 May 2013 12:46:06 GMT I had ore guardian activated, guardian bonus in that city for lvl 12... I sacked HC among one... The attacker has no higher attack than me. Still his attack is the double of mine... He can have Iron blessing activated which gives the... I had ore guardian activated, guardian bonus in that city for lvl 12...
I sacked HC among one...
The attacker has no higher attack than me.
Still his attack is the double of mine...

He can have Iron blessing activated which gives the attacker 15%, then again he has no bonus...
I'm starting to loose faith in this game, is it a glitch?.. :P

Report
[Fermer]
Battle at Vil Level 12
Glory : 0 (51,614) Sécurisé May 01, 12:16 AM
- [Supprimer mon rapport] Report No: 168254933
Defeat
Attackers breached the walls.

Gold 1,914,181
Food 2,917,192
Wood 21,272,862
Stone 1,320,764
Aetherstone 200,025

Attacker (yyy) Winner
Knight Combat Skill : 255
Attack Boosted : 20%
Defense Boosted : 20%
Attack Boost (Guardian) : 65%
(699,651) -
Troops Fought Survived Wounded
[Archer] Archer 100,000 100,000
[Heavy Cavalry] Heavy Cavalry 100,000 100,000
[Siege Wall] Siege Wall 1,000 25 ?

Throne Room
Life Debuff -34 %
Horsed Life 68 %
Defense 3411 %
Siege Attack Debuff -72.5 %
Accuracy Debuff -0.5 %
Life 145 %
Range Debuff -72.5 %
Attack Debuff -680 %
Combat Speed Debuff -61 %
Siege Load 71 %
Bonus vs. Barbarian Camps 132 %
Horsed Defense 142 %
Druid Bonus 1 15 %

Defenders (xxx)
Knight Combat Skill : 255
Attack Boosted : 20%
Defense Boosted : 20%
Defense Boost (Guardian) : 17.5%
Tour : 65
Troops Fought Survived
[Scout] Scout 222,205 0
[Heavy Cavalry] Heavy Cavalry 300,000 0
[Ballista] Ballista 100,000 0
[Battering Ram] Battering Ram 40,000 0
[Catapult] Catapult 64,122 0
[Executioner] Executioner 400 0
[Siege Wall] Siege Wall 2,200 0

Throne Room
Attack Debuff -770 %
Ranged Attack 118 %
Defense 3305 %
Siege Attack Debuff -72.5 %
Accuracy Debuff -0.5 %
Life 145 %
Range Debuff -72.5 %
Horsed Life 203 %
Combat Speed Debuff -95 %
Defense Debuff -261 %
Life Debuff -38 %
Construction Speed 41 %
Range 78 %
Bonus
Troops Attacker Life Attack Defense Speed Range Load
[Archer] 1335 1286.505 874.375 125 1836 50
[Heavy Cavalry] 9380 5253.22875 4432.911 1155 84 224
[Siege Wall] 22428 1072.0875 4896.5 387.5 90 1000

Troops Defenser Life Attack Defense Speed Range Load
[Scout] 63.685 16.95 36.525 1500 21.1
[Heavy Cavalry] 11844 2768.5 4448.745 1155 118.16
[Ballista] 2037.92 2542.5 1461 110 2597
[Battering Ram] 31842.5 1412.5 1461 132 633
[Catapult] 3056.88 3390 1826.25 88 2782.5
[Executioner] 13373.85 4802.5 2556.75 250 126.6
[Siege Wall] 26747.7 565 5113.5 387.5 126.6

Research Life Attack Defense Speed Range Load
Attacker : 60 % 60 % 60 % 60 % 60 % 100 %
Defenser : 60 % 60 % 60 % 60 % 60 %
Research Britton Cartography Defenses Strengthen Fletching
Attacker : 50 % 5 % 18 % 18 %
Defenser : 50 % 50 % 20 % 20 %

Might Lost (yyy) : 12.6k Might Lost (xxx) : 4480.2k
Losses: 4.4M ]]> Battle Reports Explained KackaRoach http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?173240-Can-someone-explain-this-report http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?172861-Can-someone-help-explain-this-to-me-please&goto=newpost Mon, 29 Apr 2013 22:58:56 GMT Here's a report I need help with:

Attackers () Winner
Knight Combat Skill: 255
Attack Boosted: 20%
Defense Boosted: 20%
Attack Results:
Might Lost: 230,727
(498,592) undefined
Troops Fought Survived Killed
Heavy Cavalry 330,000 297,039 (32,961)
Unit Stats:
HP: 4,480 Atk: 6,287.955625 Def: 901.929 Spd: 2,110.5 Rng: 280
Throne Room Bonuses:
Attack: 339%
Defense: 316%
Range: 316%
Bonus to PvP on Offense: 77%
Bonus to Wall: 205%
Attack Debuff: -77%
Defense Debuff: -184%
Combat Speed Debuff: -77%
Range Debuff: -194%
Load Debuff: -41%
Infantry Life Debuff: -15%
Ranged Life: 171%
Ranged Attack Debuff: -61%
Horsed Combat Speed: 118%
Siege Attack: 38%
Siege Range: 30%
Siege Range Debuff: -15%
Reinforcement March Speed: 164%
Troop Training Speed: 84%
Construction Speed: 132%
Wood Production: 246%

Defenders ()
Knight Combat Skill: 255
Attack Boosted: 20%
Defense Boosted: 20%
Defense Results:
Might Lost: 2,308,663
Rounds: 3
Troops Fought Survived Killed
Heavy Cavalry 329,809 0 (329,809)
Trebuchet 7,249 7,249
Caltrops 3,008 3,008
Unit Stats:
HP: 5,475.2 Atk: 1,977.5 Def: 3,057.615 Spd: 825 Rng: 60
HP: 0 Atk: 2,550 Def: 0 Spd: 0 Rng: 0
HP: 240 Atk: 2,583.75 Def: 0 Spd: 0 Rng: 0
Throne Room Bonuses:
Defense: 3177%
Attack Debuff: -918%
Combat Speed Debuff: -77%
Load Debuff: -91%
Ranged Life: 77%
Horsed Defense: 174%
Horsed Life: 76%
Troop Training Speed: 152%
Upkeep Reduction: 33%
Research Speed: 68%
Aetherstone Cap: 61%
Storehouse Protection: 94%
Chance to Find Items in Dark Forests: 38%

How were there so few losses on the attacker side and wiped out the defender (even assuming the attacker sacced some hc which added 252 to the hc's original 700)? The hc attack stats are over 6k, how? when the attack debuff brought it down to minimum? Did the high range take out that 3k defence?

Thanks ]]> Battle Reports Explained Asgenar http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?172861-Can-someone-help-explain-this-to-me-please http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?172642-Eliminate-the-random-variable&goto=newpost Sun, 28 Apr 2013 18:57:20 GMT Hey everyone, I do not need the battle report explained, I just want everyone to look it over. With troops being purchased more and more(that 3 gem box was pretty nice if you buy troop bundles), My concern is that in the future the biggest... Hey everyone,

I do not need the battle report explained, I just want everyone to look it over.

With troops being purchased more and more(that 3 gem box was pretty nice if you buy troop bundles), My concern is that in the future the biggest spenders will only ever have to turn on range and splat high defense troops. The random variable in koc allows you to kill x amount of troops per wave, even if you have a high enough defense value to run things over. If you have enough troops firing in 1 round(in this instance 95 million catapults), it does not matter what your attack value is of your troops, you will splat even a wave like this. Now i could potentially just send 300-400k siege walls + ballista or catapults the next time...but if someone was sending 300k siege walls at you...what tr did you think they were choosing? lol

I'm not saying I want things changed from a battle perspective, I just want to hear other people's opinions on it. I don't have a really strong feeling on it either way, but I feel that regardless of how much you spend in the game you should be able to make someone that makes a mistake lose troops.

Attackers (Balrog_)
Knight Combat Skill: 255
Attack Boosted: 20%
Defense Boosted: 20%
Attack Results:
Might Lost: 7,825,000
(51,6) undefined
Troops Fought Survived Killed
Ballista 725,000 0 (725,000)
Siege Wall 100,000 0 (100,000)
Unit Stats:
HP: 2,912 Atk: 6,754.15125 Def: 1,769.32 Spd: 224 Rng: 3,038
HP: 38,220 Atk: 1,500.9225 Def: 6,192.62 Spd: 1,085 Rng: 126
Throne Room Bonuses:
Defense: 2927%
Life: 222%
Attack Debuff: -792%
Defense Debuff: -77%
Life Debuff: -19%
Range Debuff: -72.5%
Accuracy Debuff: -0.5%
Infantry Combat Speed: 77%
Infantry Defense Debuff: -61%
Infantry Life Debuff: -38%
Ranged Attack: 127%
Horsed Defense: 174%
Horsed Load: 33%
Siege Accuracy: 0.66%
Siege Attack Debuff: -72.5%
Druid Bonus 1: 15%

Defenders (xxx) Winner
Knight Combat Skill: 255
Attack Boosted: 20%
Defense Boosted: 20%
Defense Results:
Might Lost: 80,790
Rounds: 6
Troops Fought Survived Killed
Supply Troop ??? ??? 0
Militiaman ??? ??? 0
Scout ??? ??? (40,395)
Pikeman ??? ??? 0
Swordsman ??? ??? 0
Archer ??? ??? 0
Cavalry ??? ??? 0
Heavy Cavalry ??? ??? 0
Supply Wagon ??? ??? 0
Ballista ??? ??? 0
Battering Ram ??? ??? 0
Catapult ??? ??? 0
Bloodthorn ??? ??? 0
Executioner ??? ??? 0
Unit Stats:
HP: 847.9 Atk: 28.25 Def: 28.185 Spd: 180 Rng: 25
HP: 1,695.8 Atk: 282.5 Def: 122.135 Spd: 200 Rng: 50
HP: 84.79 Atk: 16.95 Def: 9.395 Spd: 3,000 Rng: 50
HP: 2,543.7 Atk: 847.5 Def: 310.035 Spd: 300 Rng: 125
HP: 2,967.65 Atk: 565 Def: 591.885 Spd: 275 Rng: 75
HP: 2,119.75 Atk: 678 Def: 234.875 Spd: 250 Rng: 3,960
HP: 4,819 Atk: 1,412.5 Def: 450.225 Spd: 1,600 Rng: 250
HP: 13,493.2 Atk: 2,768.5 Def: 1,218.609 Spd: 1,680 Rng: 280
HP: 6,746.6 Atk: 56.5 Def: 150.075 Spd: 240 Rng: 25
HP: 3,084.16 Atk: 2,542.5 Def: 400.2 Spd: 160 Rng: 4,620
HP: 48,190 Atk: 1,412.5 Def: 400.2 Spd: 192 Rng: 1,500
HP: 6,476.736 Atk: 4,746 Def: 700.35 Spd: 179.2 Rng: 6,930
HP: 10,119.9 Atk: 3,672.5 Def: 450.225 Spd: 900 Rng: 375
HP: 20,239.8 Atk: 4,802.5 Def: 700.35 Spd: 500 Rng: 300
Throne Room Bonuses:
Defense: 730%
Life: 175%
Range: 431.5%
Accuracy: 1.2%
Attack Debuff: -172%
Defense Debuff: -115%
Life Debuff: -57%
Range Debuff: -376.5%
Load Debuff: -60%
Accuracy Debuff: -0.6%
Ranged Attack: 475%
Ranged Attack Debuff: -115%
Horsed Defense Debuff: -91%
Siege Attack: 151%
Siege Attack Debuff: -134.5%
Food Production: 175%
Druid Bonus 1: 15% ]]> Battle Reports Explained Balrog http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?172642-Eliminate-the-random-variable http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?172559-can-someone-explain-this&goto=newpost Sun, 28 Apr 2013 05:11:08 GMT Glory Gained: 996 Attackers (Czardes) Knight Combat Skill: 255 Attack Boosted: 20% Defense Boosted: 20% Attack Results: Might Lost: 2,656,500 (300,170) undefined Troops Fought Survived Killed Heavy Cavalry 379,500 0 (379,500) Glory Gained: 996
Attackers (Czardes)
Knight Combat Skill: 255
Attack Boosted: 20%
Defense Boosted: 20%
Attack Results:
Might Lost: 2,656,500
(300,170) undefined
Troops Fought Survived Killed
Heavy Cavalry 379,500 0 (379,500)
Unit Stats:
HP: 6,100 Atk: 8,688.666875 Def: 3,077.625 Spd: 1,087.5 Rng: 60
Throne Room Bonuses:
Defense: 3332%
Life: 145%
Attack Debuff: -972%
Life Debuff: -47%
Range Debuff: -72.5%
Accuracy Debuff: -0.5%
Infantry Defense: 145%
Horsed Attack: 219%
Horsed Defense: 804%
Siege Attack Debuff: -72.5%
Chance to Find Items: 18.5%
Druid Bonus 1: 15%

Defenders (Steele) Winner
Knight Combat Skill: 255


Defense Results:
Might Lost: 35,363,168
Rounds: 50
Troops Fought Survived Killed
Scout 5,513,461 0 (5,513,461)
Pikeman 530 0 (530)
Swordsman 1,034,300 0 (1,034,300)
Archer 2,528,174 2,381,769 (146,405)
Cavalry 189,202 0 (189,202)
Heavy Cavalry 2,160,510 0 (2,160,510)
Supply Wagon 275,125 0 (275,125)
Ballista 33,950 33,950
Battering Ram 298,900 0 (298,900)
Catapult 786,168 786,168
Bloodthorn 1,801 0 (1,801)
Executioner 13,155 0 (13,155)
Siege Wall 1,036 0 (1,036)
Crossbows 2,695 2,695
Trap 500 0 (500)
Unit Stats:
HP: 72 Atk: 15.75 Def: 33.265 Spd: 3,000 Rng: 15
HP: 2,160 Atk: 787.5 Def: 1,097.745 Spd: 300 Rng: 37.5
HP: 2,520 Atk: 525 Def: 2,095.695 Spd: 275 Rng: 22.5
HP: 1,800 Atk: 630 Def: 831.625 Spd: 250 Rng: 1,860
HP: 2,580 Atk: 1,312.5 Def: 1,533.825 Spd: 1,600 Rng: 75
HP: 5,160 Atk: 1,837.5 Def: 2,965.395 Spd: 1,200 Rng: 60
HP: 3,612 Atk: 52.5 Def: 498.975 Spd: 240 Rng: 7.5
HP: 1,651.2 Atk: 2,362.5 Def: 1,330.6 Spd: 160 Rng: 2,170
HP: 25,800 Atk: 1,312.5 Def: 1,330.6 Spd: 192 Rng: 450
HP: 2,476.8 Atk: 3,150 Def: 1,663.25 Spd: 128 Rng: 2,325
HP: 5,418 Atk: 3,412.5 Def: 1,496.925 Spd: 900 Rng: 112.5
HP: 10,836 Atk: 4,462.5 Def: 2,328.55 Spd: 500 Rng: 90
HP: 21,672 Atk: 525 Def: 4,657.1 Spd: 775 Rng: 90
HP: 3,200 Atk: 2,145 Def: 96 Spd: 0 Rng: 2,340
HP: 0 Atk: 5,000 Def: 0 Spd: 0 Rng: 0
Throne Room Bonuses:
Defense: 3019%
Life: 145%
Defense Debuff: -926%
Range Debuff: -72.5%
Accuracy Debuff: -0.5%
Infantry Attack: 77%
Infantry Life: 205%
Horsed Attack: 433%
Horsed Defense: 82%
Siege Accuracy: 0.37%
Siege Attack Debuff: -72.5%
Ore Production: 510%
Chance to Find Items in Dark Forests: 38%
Druid Bonus 1: 15% ]]> Battle Reports Explained steeleV http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?172559-can-someone-explain-this http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?172077-please-explaine-how-i-lose-so-bad&goto=newpost Fri, 26 Apr 2013 00:24:30 GMT attle at (285,349) Apr 25, 08:08 PM Report No: 154330914 Attackers breached the walls. Glory Gained: 0 Loot: Gold 3,194,572 Food 6,461,399 Wood 230,883,132 Stone 685,879 attle at (285,349) Apr 25, 08:08 PM
Report No: 154330914
Attackers breached the walls.

Glory Gained: 0
Loot:
Gold 3,194,572
Food 6,461,399
Wood 230,883,132
Stone 685,879
Ore 274,133

Attackers (Fabers) Winner
Knight Combat Skill: 255
Attack Boosted: 20%
Defense Boosted: 20%
Attack Results:
Might Lost: 96,187
(266,79) undefined
Troops Fought Survived Killed
Heavy Cavalry 716,100 702,359 (13,741)
Unit Stats:
HP: 6,468 Atk: 6,287.955625 Def: 4,770.297 Spd: 1,102.5 Rng: 84
Throne Room Bonuses:
Defense: 3053%
Life: 118%
Bonus vs. Barbarian Camps: 164%
Attack Debuff: -792%
Defense Debuff: -77%
Combat Speed Debuff: -38%
Range Debuff: -59%
Accuracy Debuff: -0.41%
Infantry Attack: 47%
Infantry Defense Debuff: -95%
Horsed Defense: 649%
Horsed Load: 87%
Horsed Defense Debuff: -145%
Horsed Combat Speed Debuff: -38%
Siege Attack Debuff: -59%
Druid Bonus 1: 15%

Defenders (bamf)
Knight Combat Skill: 255
Attack Boosted: 20%
Defense Boosted: 20%
Defense Results:
Might Lost: 32,621,284
Rounds: 46
Troops Fought Survived Killed
Heavy Cavalry 4,531,612 0 (4,531,612)
Battering Ram 100,000 0 (100,000)
Unit Stats:
HP: 9,555.84 Atk: 2,768.5 Def: 4,653.369 Spd: 1,050 Rng: 84
HP: 30,024 Atk: 1,412.5 Def: 1,529.4 Spd: 134.4 Rng: 450
Throne Room Bonuses:
Defense: 3563%
Life: 118%
Bonus vs. Barbarian Camps: 132%
Attack Debuff: -800%
Defense Debuff: -128%
Combat Speed Debuff: -77%
Range Debuff: -59%
Accuracy Debuff: -0.41%
Horsed Attack: 61%
Horsed Defense: 142%
Horsed Life: 38%
Horsed Life Debuff: -47%
Siege Attack Debuff: -59% ]]> Battle Reports Explained bamf820 http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?172077-please-explaine-how-i-lose-so-bad http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?171491-Defense-TR-Sucks-what-was-the-point-upgrading-it-for-months-Moron-kabam&goto=newpost Tue, 23 Apr 2013 08:28:52 GMT xxx Knight Combat Skill: 255 Attack Boosted: 0% Defense Boosted: 0% Attack Results: Might Lost: 3,083,850 (741,428) undefined Troops Fought Survived Killed Heavy Cavalry 440,550 0 (440,550) Unit Stats: xxx
Knight Combat Skill: 255
Attack Boosted: 0%
Defense Boosted: 0%
Attack Results:
Might Lost: 3,083,850
(741,428) undefined
Troops Fought Survived Killed
Heavy Cavalry 440,550 0 (440,550)
Unit Stats:
HP: 7,140 Atk: 6,330.555 Def: 3,004.197 Spd: 1,627.5 Rng: 138.32
Throne Room Bonuses:
Attack: 47%
Defense: 3246%
Life: 118%
Range: 23.5%
Attack Debuff: -1019%
Defense Debuff: -95%
Range Debuff: -59%
Accuracy Debuff: -0.41%
Infantry Life: 124%
Ranged Defense: 47%
Ranged Life: 61%
Horsed Attack: 95%
Horsed Defense: 210%
Siege Attack Debuff: -210%

Defenders (xxx) Winner
Knight Combat Skill: 231


Defense Results:
Might Lost: 955,682
Rounds: 3
Troops Fought Survived Killed
Scout 1,000 0 (1,000)
Archer 150,000 0 (150,000)
Ballista 199,990 160,692 (39,298)
Catapult 379,500 379,500
Unit Stats:
HP: 32 Atk: 39.21 Def: 4.845 Spd: 3,000 Rng: 23.8
HP: 800 Atk: 1,568.4 Def: 130.625 Spd: 250 Rng: 2,388
HP: 1,024 Atk: 5,247 Def: 100.2 Spd: 155 Rng: 2,786
HP: 1,536 Atk: 6,756 Def: 125.25 Spd: 124 Rng: 2,985
Throne Room Bonuses:
Attack: 1397%
Range: 78%
Bonus to Wall: 205%
Attack Debuff: -38%
Defense Debuff: -1272%
Infantry Defense: 304%
Infantry Attack Debuff: -11.5%
Ranged Defense: 38%
Horsed Life Debuff: -23%
Siege Attack: 119.5%
Siege Load: 87%
Troop Training Speed: 152%
Construction Speed: 41%
Upkeep Reduction: 33%
Research Speed: 68%
Aetherstone Cap: 61%
Storehouse Protection: 94%


basiclly after debuff from both ends. Attacker defense was 2184, where as Defender attack was 287.5

so now, Hc with 2184 defense is useless against Seige with 287 attack..
really.. ]]> Battle Reports Explained Arbab Ali http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?171491-Defense-TR-Sucks-what-was-the-point-upgrading-it-for-months-Moron-kabam http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?170889-Basics-of-the-per-round-battle-scenario&goto=newpost Fri, 19 Apr 2013 21:41:11 GMT 1. In the first round all troops, except siege walls, start separated by the range of the unit with the highest range value. 2. All troops that are alive at the start of the round will participate in each round. 3. Troops will proceed in... 1. In the first round all troops, except siege walls, start separated by the range of the unit with the highest range value.

2. All troops that are alive at the start of the round will participate in each round.

3. Troops will proceed in order of their combat speed. Generally this will go as; scouts, lc, sw, hc, bloods, executioners, pike, swords, arch, mm, st, wagons, rams, baly, cats. It should be noted that research levels, fey bonuses, and TR mods can and will cause this order to change.

4. Troops will perform a range check to see if any opponent troops are in range. The 'speed glitch' is actually a glitch in the range check system see here for details: http://community.kabam.com/forums/sh...itch-explained

5. If troops do not have an opponent with in the range check they will advance a distance equal to their combat speed.

6. If troops have an opponent with in their range check they will attack. If less then a certain amount of troops (believed to be about 10%) are needed to kill the opponent troops with in the range check the troops will also advance as well as attacking the troops.

7. Siege walls are an exception as they have unique abilities which may not yet be fully understood. My current theory on siege walls is found here: http://community.kabam.com/forums/sh...l=1#post925375

8. Horses and infantry will attack the unit that has advance the furthest distance or in the first round based on combat speed.

9. Archers, baly, and cats follow an attack priority list of: SW, Xbows, cats, baly, arch, scout, lc, hc, pike, wagons, st, mm, swords, rams, bloods, executioneer.

Calcs

# hits = # troops X accuracy (rounded down to nearest whole number, no partial hits)
damage to life per hit = attack - defense (minimum damage = 1)
hits to kill = life/damage (rounded up to the nearest whole number)
number of troops killed = # hits/hits to kill (no rounding, decreases to life carry over round to round)

accuracy table found here: http://community.kabam.com/forums/at...chmentid=48550
*note accuracy values may get updated in the future.

If I got something wrong please point it out. ]]> Battle Reports Explained former noob http://community.kabam.com/forums/showthread.php?170889-Basics-of-the-per-round-battle-scenario